跳转到主要内容
PetFoodDIY❤

Tofu, Cassava, Sodium-Based Bentonite, and Mixed Cat Litter: A Comprehensive Comparative Analysis, Market Landscape, and User Evaluation Study

1. Introduction

1.1 The Evolving Cat Litter Market

Cat litter, an indispensable product in the pet care industry, plays a crucial role in maintaining household hygiene, controlling odors, and ensuring the welfare of cats. In recent years, the global pet economy has been booming, particularly in the cat-related consumer market, which has greatly driven the innovation and diversification of cat litter products. Pet owners' increasing demands for product performance, safety, environmental friendliness, and convenience have led to the emergence of various materials and formulas of cat litter on the market. Understanding the characteristics, market performance, and user feedback of different types of cat litter is of great significance for consumers to make informed choices, retailers to optimize their product selection, and manufacturers to develop new products.

This report aims to conduct a comprehensive and in-depth comparative analysis of four mainstream cat litter types: tofu cat litter, cassava cat litter, sodium-based bentonite cat litter, and mixed cat litter. We will systematically discuss their composition, advantages and disadvantages, market share, and trends, and combine user evaluations and professional test results to provide a detailed and reliable reference for all parties involved.

1.2 Report Scope and Research Method

This report will follow the following structure: first, we will conduct an independent analysis of each type of cat litter, detailing its characteristics; second, we will make a horizontal comparison to highlight their respective advantages and disadvantages; third, we will discuss related market dynamics, especially the role of the Chinese market; and finally, we will integrate consumer insights and actual use evaluations.

The research method is based on a comprehensive analysis of existing information, including product descriptions, market research reports, patent documents, consumer reviews, and comparison test results released by third-party institutions, aiming to objectively and comprehensively present the real situation of various cat litters.

2. In-Depth Comparative Analysis of Cat Litter Types

2.1 Tofu Cat Litter

  • Composition and Morphological Variants: Tofu cat litter is mainly made from natural plant fibers, with common raw materials including soybean (yellow bean) residue, pea fiber, cornstarch, and others. There are various forms on the market, such as common strip-shaped, crushed mineral-like (mineral type), and rice grain-shaped. The particle diameter is usually between 1.5mm and 3mm. These differences in form and size directly affect their performance: for example, cat litters with finer diameters (such as mineral or rice grain types) usually have better clumping and odor-encapsulating capabilities but are more prone to producing dust and being tracked out of the litter box by cats; while cat litters with coarser diameters (such as strip-shaped) are less likely to be tracked but have relatively weaker clumping and odor-removing capabilities.
  • Advantages:
    • Environmental Friendliness and Biodegradability: The composition is natural, and many products utilize discarded materials like tofu residue as raw materials, belonging to renewable resources and being environmentally friendly. Some products can be composted.
    • Flushable: Many brands of tofu cat litter are designed to be water-soluble and can be directly flushed into the toilet for disposal, greatly improving convenience. However, it is necessary to confirm that the product has good water solubility, consider the family's pipe conditions, and adopt a method of flushing a small amount at a time to avoid clogging. The test by Shanghai Municipal Consumer Protection Commission showed that the water dissolution time of several tofu cat litters was about 22-24 seconds.
    • Less Initial Dust: Compared to bentonite cat litter, tofu cat litter produces less dust when first used.
    • Lightweight: The material is relatively light, making it convenient for consumers to carry and clean daily.
    • High Safety: Usually, food-grade raw materials are used, so even if cats or children in the home accidentally ingest a small amount, the risk is relatively low.
    • Water Absorption and Clumping (General): Some test reports believe that its water absorption and clumping capabilities are good, able to quickly absorb urine and form clumps, making it convenient to clean. However, there are also views that its clumping capability may not be as good as bentonite cat litter.
  • Disadvantages:
    • Higher Cost: The production process is relatively complex, resulting in a higher unit price than traditional bentonite cat litter.
    • Susceptible to Moisture and Deterioration: Plant fiber materials easily absorb moisture from the air, and if stored improperly, they may become moldy, clump, or breed small insects.
    • Later-Stage Dust Problem: Although there is less dust initially, after using for a period (such as 2-3 weeks) or being exposed to moisture, the amount of dust may significantly increase, and even powderization may occur.
    • Inconsistent Odor-Control Capability: There are divergent evaluations regarding its odor-control effect. Some sources believe its odor-control capability is good, while others evaluate it as ordinary or not as good as bentonite cat litter. The test results from the Shanghai Municipal Consumer Protection Commission showed that tofu cat litter had the weakest overall odor-control effect. Additionally, the inherent bean smell may not be accepted by all users or cats.
    • Hygiene Risks: The test by the Shanghai Municipal Consumer Protection Commission pointed out that tofu cat litter performed poorly in terms of hygiene indicators, detecting various residues (such as zearalenone, a mycotoxin).
    • Cat Acceptance: Some cats may not like the texture or smell of tofu cat litter.
  • Balancing the Characteristics of Tofu Cat Litter: The core appeal of tofu cat litter lies in its environmental concept and flushable convenience. However, obtaining these advantages often comes with a series of compromises. Its higher price, potential hygiene issues due to sensitivity to environmental humidity (such as mold, insect breeding, and mycotoxin risks), increased dust in the later stages of use, and possibly inferior performance in key indicators (such as odor control) compared to mainstream products (bentonite cat litter) are significant limiting factors. This indicates that although tofu cat litter caters to the values of a specific consumer group (environmental friendliness, convenience), it may require users to invest more effort in management (such as paying attention to storage, frequently changing the litter) and may not fully meet the demands of users who prioritize performance and cost-effectiveness. The differences in performance evaluations from various sources (such as odor control capability) also suggest that there are significant quality gaps between different brands of tofu cat litter on the market.

2.2. Tapioca Cat Litter

  • Ingredients: The main ingredient is tapioca (also known as cassava) starch, often mixed with other plant-based ingredients such as cornstarch, pea fiber, and others to create a cat litter alternative. The market positioning is usually natural and plant-based.
  • Advantages:
    • Biodegradable and Eco-Friendly: Made from renewable plant resources, it aligns with the eco-friendly trend.
    • Good Clumping Ability: Generally, it has a good clumping effect and can quickly form solid clumps. Some reviews consider its clumping ability superior to other natural cat litters.
    • Good Odor Control: Often considered effective in controlling odors, sometimes utilizing the natural properties of the ingredients or adding enzymes to enhance the effect.
    • Low Dust: Advertisements and user reviews often emphasize its low dust or dust-free characteristics.
    • Lightweight: Compared to mineral cat litters, it is easier to carry.
    • Soft Texture: Usually considered friendly to cats' paws.
    • High Safety: Plant-based, food-grade ingredients, with a low risk of harm if ingested in small amounts. Its light color helps observe the cat's urine color, monitoring health conditions.
  • Disadvantages:
    • Easy to Track: Can be easily tracked out of the litter box by the cat's paws, especially with finer grain versions. There are also larger grain versions on the market to reduce tracking issues.
    • Higher Cost: Usually positioned as a high-end product, with prices possibly higher than traditional cat litters. However, some sources list it as medium-priced.
    • Limited Purchase Channels: Compared to bentonite or tofu cat litter, it may have lower market penetration and purchasing convenience.
    • Prone to Attracting Pests/Deterioration: As a plant-based product, if not stored properly or changed frequently, it may attract pests or become moldy. Similar to other grain-based cat litters, there are concerns about risks such as aflatoxin.
    • Uncertain Flushability: Not recommended to flush down the toilet, or such recommendations are cautious. The hard clumps it forms may not dissolve easily in water.
    • Clump Integrity: Although its clumping ability is generally recognized, some reviews mention that clumps can be brittle or prone to breaking apart.
  • Market Positioning of Tapioca Cat Litter: Tapioca cat litter is often marketed as a high-performance, "natural and high-end" choice. It aims to match or surpass bentonite cat litter in key performance indicators (such as clumping and odor control) while offering the benefits of natural ingredients (such as biodegradability, safety, and low dust). However, this positioning usually comes with a higher price tag and some common issues with plant-based cat litters (such as tracking, attracting pests, and limited purchase channels). This means tapioca cat litter is mainly targeted at consumers willing to pay a premium for health, sustainability, and performance without many compromises.

2.3. Sodium-Based Bentonite Cat Litter

  • Ingredients: The main ingredient is sodium-based bentonite, a type of clay mineral known for its high montmorillonite content, which expands when it comes into contact with water and has strong absorbency. Another type is calcium-based bentonite, sometimes considered to have a lower risk of harm if ingested due to its natural healing properties, but sodium-based bentonite is more commonly used for its superior clumping performance.
  • Advantages:
    • Excellent Clumping Ability: Forms hard, cohesive clumps when wet, making it easy to scoop and less likely to crumble.
    • Highly Effective Odor Control: Generally considered to effectively absorb and lock in odors. Test results from the Shanghai Consumer Protection Commission also support its superior odor-controlling effect. However, there are evaluations with lower ratings for its odor control, possibly due to differences in product formulas (such as the addition of baking soda or activated carbon) and testing methods.
    • High Cat Acceptance: The grain texture is very similar to natural sand, fitting the cat's natural behavior, so most cats are happy to use it. On-site evaluations also confirm cats' preference for it.
    • Cost-Effective: Usually the cheapest option by unit price. Its efficient clumping ability also means it can be more economical in use.
  • Disadvantages:
    • High Dust Content: Easily produces a large amount of dust, especially when pouring, scooping, or when cats dig, posing a potential threat to the respiratory system of both cats and humans. Although there are low-dust formulas on the market, their effectiveness varies.
    • Heavy Weight: High density makes the cat litter very heavy, causing inconvenience in carrying and waste disposal. The high density also increases transportation costs.
    • Environmental Impact: The mining of bentonite (usually open-pit mining) has some environmental impact. The product itself is not biodegradable, increasing the burden on landfills.
    • Cannot be Flushed: Absolutely cannot be flushed down the toilet, as its strong expansion can cause severe pipe blockages.
    • Easy to Track: Fine particles can easily stick to the cat's paws and fur, being tracked to other parts of the house, creating a "desertification" phenomenon.
    • Health Concerns (Ingestion): Cats may ingest small amounts of cat litter when grooming their paws. Sodium-based bentonite expands significantly with water, raising concerns about potential blockages in the body. Although its direct link to feline urinary system diseases is controversial or denied, the risk of ingestion remains a concern for some users. It is suggested that calcium-based bentonite may have a lower risk of harm if ingested.
  • Market Position of Bentonite Cat Litter: Bentonite cat litter, with its undeniable advantages—excellent clumping ability, widely recognized strong odor control, high cat acceptance, and low price—has long dominated the market, occupying a leading position. These factors explain why it has such a high market share. However, its significant disadvantages—serious dust problems and associated health risks, environmental burden from mining and disposal, heavy weight, annoying tracking issues, and the inconvenience of not being flushable—have driven the development and popularity of alternative products. The fact that bentonite cat litter remains popular despite its drawbacks highlights the challenges alternative products face in fully surpassing its core performance and cost advantages. Innovations in bentonite cat litter mainly focus on mitigating its disadvantages (such as developing low-dust formulas), while the growth of alternative products indicates consumers' willingness to pay more for health, convenience (such as flushability), or sustainability, even if it means sacrificing some performance. The inconsistency in evaluating its odor control effect also reminds us that differences in brand and formula are key factors influencing product quality, even within the same category.

2.4. Mixed Cat Litter (Mixed Cat Sand)

  • Concept and Composition: Mixed cat litter is a blend of different materials (such as tofu + bentonite, tofu + cassava, tofu + wood chips, plant-based + mineral, often with added functional ingredients like activated carbon, zeolite, baking soda, tannin, probiotics, and fragrance) in specific proportions, aiming to combine the advantages of various single-material cat litters while compensating for their individual shortcomings. Patent document 27/27 details various mixing ratios (such as 7:3 tofu:bentonite, 4:3:3 bentonite:cylindrical tofu:spherical tofu) and the application of additives.
  • Advantages:
    • Balanced Performance: Committed to providing a "taking the strengths and making up for the weaknesses" solution, seeking better comprehensive performance in multiple dimensions such as clumping, odor control, dust control, and even flushability compared to single-material cat litters. The Shanghai Consumer Protection Commission's test gave mixed cat litter a very high comprehensive evaluation.
    • Enhanced Odor Control: Can more effectively integrate various odor-controlling components (such as activated carbon, zeolite, nano-carbon crystal, tannin, probiotics), achieving stronger odor control effects than some basic materials themselves.
    • Reduced Dust (Compared to Pure Bentonite): By mixing in lighter, less dusty materials like tofu and cassava, the overall dust level of the mixture can be effectively reduced. Shanghai tests also confirmed its good dust control performance.
    • Improved Clumping (Compared to Pure Plant-Based Sand): Adding bentonite can significantly enhance the clumping strength and ability to wrap excrement of plant-based cat litter.
    • Potential Flushability (Containing Tofu Ingredients): Mixed cat litter containing tofu ingredients may be easier to decompose in water compared to pure bentonite cat litter, providing a certain degree of flushability convenience, but still requires cautious use.
    • Customization Potential: Allows manufacturers to adjust different mixing schemes according to specific needs (such as multi-cat households, automatic cat litter box applicability, special fragrance preferences).
  • Disadvantages:
    • Large Performance Differences: The final effect highly depends on the specifically chosen materials, mixing ratios, and the quality of the raw materials. Not all mixed cat litters can achieve an ideal balance.
    • Complexity and Cost: Formula design and production processes may be more complex, and costs may be higher than basic bentonite cat litter, but perhaps lower than some high-end pure natural cat litters.
    • Possible Compromises: In pursuit of balance, mixed cat litter may not reach the extreme in any single performance indicator (for example, clumping hardness may be slightly inferior to top-level pure bentonite, and flushability may not be as good as high-quality pure tofu sand).
    • Transparency Issues: If product labels are not clear enough, consumers may find it difficult to accurately understand the specific component composition and expected performance.
  • Market Significance of Mixed Cat Litter: The rise and growing popularity of mixed cat litter directly reflect the inherent limitations of single-material cat litters and unmet user demands. Manufacturers are actively using mixed formulas as an important innovation strategy to solve the pain points encountered by consumers when using pure bentonite cat litter (dust, environmental issues, non-flushability) and potential problems when using pure plant-based cat litter (clumping, odor control, cost, hygiene risks). The goal is to optimize performance and achieve better balance. The high score evaluation in the Shanghai Consumer Protection Commission's test also verifies the potential of this approach. This indicates that mixed cat litter is an important market trend, representing a development towards customization and performance optimization. In the future, this field is likely to continue to emerge with innovative products adopting new material combinations and functional additives. However, this also brings new challenges to consumers, who need to more carefully research specific mixing formulas, as the "mixed cat litter" label itself cannot guarantee its specific characteristics (for example, whether it is completely flushable depends on its composition). Therefore, clearer product labels and standardized third-party testing (such as the detection services mentioned in 36) will become increasingly important in helping consumers make choices.

2.5. Summary Table of Key Performance Comparison of Cat Litter Types

To more intuitively compare these four types of cat litters, the following table summarizes the key performance indicators analyzed in the previous text:

Performance Indicator Tofu Cat Litter Cassava Cat Litter Sodium Bentonite Cat Litter Mixed Cat Litter
Main Raw Material Tofu dregs/pea fiber, starch, etc. plant fiber Cassava starch, corn starch, etc. plant starch Sodium bentonite (clay mineral) Multiple materials mixed (such as tofu + bentonite, plant + mineral + additives)
Clumping Ability Good (may not be as good as bentonite) Excellent Excellent+ Good to Excellent+ (depends on the formula)
Odor Control Ability Fair to Good (evaluations vary) Good to Excellent Excellent to Excellent+ (evaluations vary) Good to Excellent+ (depends on the formula and additives)
Dust Level Low to Medium (initially low, may increase later) Low High (low-dust formulas exist) Low to Medium (usually better than pure bentonite)
Tracking Medium (striped types are less, granular types are more) Medium to High (fine particles are easy to track) High Low to Medium (depends on the formula)
Environmental Friendliness Yes (biodegradable, renewable raw materials) Yes (biodegradable, renewable raw materials) No (mining affects the environment, non-degradable) No to Yes (depends on the mixed composition)
Flushable Yes (requires caution, confirms solubility) No/Caution (usually not recommended) No No/Caution (depends on whether it contains soluble components)
Weight Light Light Heavy Medium (usually between plant-based sand and bentonite)
Usual Cost Medium to High Medium to High Low Medium (usually higher than bentonite, lower than high-end natural sand)
Cat Acceptance Medium (some cats may not like the smell/texture) Good (soft texture) High (most similar to natural sand) Good to High (depends on the bentonite content and texture)
Core Advantages Environmental friendliness, flushability convenience Natural high performance, low dust Extreme clumping, low cost, high acceptance Balanced performance, customizable optimization
Core Disadvantages High cost, susceptible to moisture, later-stage dust, hygiene risks High cost, easy tracking, purchase inconvenience, plant-based inherent problems (pests/decay) High dust, environmental burden, heavy, non-flushable, easy tracking Performance depends on the formula, may have no outstanding advantages, transparency issues

3. Market Dynamics and Usage Patterns

3.1. Global Cat Litter Market Overview

The global cat litter market is substantial and continues to grow. According to Fortune Business Insights, the global bentonite cat litter market size was approximately $2.83 billion in 2021 and is expected to grow to $4.11 billion by 2029, with a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 4.82% from 2022 to 2029. Another report predicts that the global bentonite cat litter market size will be $3.1 billion in 2024 and will reach $4.4 billion by 2031, with a CAGR of 5.2% from 2024 to 2031.

The key factors driving market growth include the increasing rate of pet ownership worldwide, particularly the growing number of cat-owning households (approximately 370 million pet cats worldwide); the deepening trend of pet humanization, with owners willing to invest more in their pets' health and comfort; increasing disposable income; growing concern for pet hygiene and health; and the continuous innovation of cat litter products, such as the development of more environmentally friendly, low-dust, odor-controlling, or specially functional formulas.

In terms of regions, Europe and North America are the primary cat litter consumption markets, benefiting from their high pet ownership rates. For example, the recorded number of pet cats in Europe has exceeded 113 million. The pet industry expenditure in the United States was $123.6 billion in 2021, and the proportion of cat-owning households is continuously rising. Meanwhile, developing regions such as the Asia-Pacific, South America, the Middle East, and Africa also show significant market growth potential.

3.2. Bentonite Cat Litter: Market Leaders and China's Core Position

Despite facing numerous challenges, bentonite cat litter, with its performance and cost advantages, remains the dominant force in the global market, occupying the majority of the market share (estimated to be as high as 70-80% or considered to occupy the main share).

In the global supply chain of bentonite cat litter, China plays a crucial role, particularly in Ningcheng County, Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region. The region is rich in bentonite mineral resources (with a reserve of over 16 million tons and potential reserves of 2 billion tons), and has developed into China's and the world's largest bentonite cat litter production base. According to reports, Ningcheng County's bentonite cat litter output accounts for about two-thirds of the national total output, one-third of Asia's output, and around 20% of the global market share. The local area has over 30 cat litter production enterprises, with an annual total output of over 2 million tons, and products are sold to over 100 countries and regions worldwide. These enterprises mostly started as townships and, after more than 20 years of development, have formed an industrial cluster integrating mining, processing, research and development, production, and sales (including cross-border e-commerce).

The concentrated development of the Ningcheng cat litter industry has brought about scale economies and specialization advantages, which are undoubtedly important factors in bentonite cat litter's ability to maintain cost competitiveness. However, such highly concentrated production may also bring potential supply chain risks, such as geopolitical fluctuations, logistics interruptions, or local environmental protection policies tightening the impact on mining and production activities. Notably, the local cat litter industry in Ningcheng has realized that it cannot rely solely on traditional, low-value products and is actively investing in research and development, transforming and upgrading to high-value products such as lightweight cat litter, water-soluble cat litter, and striving to improve product quality (such as increasing the pass rate and reducing dust) and technological content. This indicates that the industrial cluster itself is also seeking breakthroughs and diversified development to respond to market competition and potential risks.

3.3. Market Share and Trends of Alternative Cat Litters

Tofu cat litter, tapioca cat litter, and mixed cat litter, as the main challengers to bentonite cat litter, are striving to gain market share. Although precise global or Chinese market share data (especially for tapioca cat litter) is relatively lacking, some regional data can provide reference. For example, in the Taiwan market, it is estimated that tofu cat litter accounts for about 15-20%, wood shavings account for about 5-10%, and tapioca cat litter, crystal cat litter, and paper sand, etc., combined account for about 10-20%.

It is worth noting the latest trends from the Chinese mainland market. According to the "2025 China Pet Industry White Paper", compared to 2023, consumers' preference for mixed cat litter and bentonite cat litter has significantly increased, with mixed cat litter's preference increasing by 8.3 percentage points and bentonite cat litter increasing by 3.6 percentage points. This indicates that despite concerns about the drawbacks of bentonite cat litter, its core advantages are still recognized, and mixed cat litter, which can provide more balanced performance, is gaining popularity.

The overall growth trend of natural/plant-based cat litter (including tofu, tapioca, wood shavings, corn, etc.) is clear, mainly driven by consumers' increasing emphasis on environmental sustainability and pet health.

The simultaneous increase in preference for bentonite and mixed cat litter in the Chinese market, at first glance, seems somewhat contradictory, as if it's not a simple "mineral vs. natural" replacement battle. However, combining the previous analysis (mixed cat litter is a market response to the imperfections of single materials), this more likely reflects that consumers are not completely abandoning the core advantages of bentonite (performance, cost), but are seeking improvement or balance for its shortcomings. Mixed cat litter provides one path (combining bentonite with plant materials), while the improvement of bentonite itself (such as low-dust technology) provides another path. In contrast, tofu cat litter performs relatively weakly in some key performance tests (such as hygiene, odor control), which may explain why its growth momentum is not as strong as mixed cat litter or improved bentonite cat litter in the latest preference data. This indicates that the market is not simply transitioning from minerals to natural materials, but is moving towards a more segmented, optimal solution-seeking direction. Future successful products will need to either significantly overcome the inherent weaknesses of bentonite (such as high-end natural or mixed cat litter) or provide performance-optimized bentonite products. Those primarily relying on single convenience (such as flushability) but with suboptimal performance or cost may face greater market pressure, unless they can achieve breakthroughs in performance or price.

4. Consumer Insights and Actual Evaluation

4.1. User Reviews and Professional Testing Results Integration

To gain a more comprehensive understanding of the actual performance of various cat litters, we will combine user feedback with professional third-party testing results.

The Shanghai Consumer Protection Commission's comparative test of 20 cat litters provided some quantifiable data and conclusions:

  • Comprehensive Evaluation: Mixed cat litter and bentonite cat litter received the highest five-star rating, crystal cat litter and pine cat litter received four and a half stars, and tofu cat litter received four stars.
  • Cat Preference: On-site testing of nearly 30 cats showed that they clearly preferred bentonite cat litter, followed by mixed cat litter. This is related to the fact that bentonite cat litter has a texture similar to natural sand.
  • Hygiene: Crystal cat litter performed best, while tofu cat litter performed the worst, with multiple residual substances detected. Pine cat litter was found to contain formaldehyde.
  • Performance:
    • Water Absorption and Clumping: Mixed cat litter performed best in terms of water absorption rate and clumping (high strength, not easy to scatter, and economical). Pine cat litter also had a high water absorption rate.
    • Dust Control: Mixed cat litter performed best in terms of dust content before and after use. Crystal cat litter and tofu cat litter had low initial dust, but their powderization rate increased significantly after use. Pine cat litter had no initial dust, but its powderization rate surged after disintegration.
    • Odor Removal and Inhibition: Bentonite cat litter had the best overall odor removal effect, while tofu cat litter was the weakest. Among the tested samples, pine cat litter had better inhibitory effects.
    • Tofu Litter Solubility: All four tested tofu cat litters could dissolve and disintegrate within 25 seconds.

User reviews and forum discussions (such as reviews of cassava cat litter and recommendations for mixed cat litter) provided richer qualitative information and actual use experiences:

  • Tofu Cat Litter: Users appreciated its convenience of being flushable, but were concerned about its ease of moisture absorption, mold growth, and increased dust in the later stages, as well as poor clumping and odor removal effects from some brands.
  • Cassava Cat Litter: Its excellent clumping ability, low dust, and good odor control were well-received. However, its high price and tracking issues were common complaints. Brands like Sustainably Yours (corn-cassava mix) and FUKUMARU were frequently mentioned.
  • Bentonite Cat Litter: Users generally recognized its strong clumping and odor removal effects, as well as its high cost-performance ratio. However, dust issues were the biggest drawback, followed by weight and tracking problems. Brands like ARM & HAMMER (iron hammer) and EverClean (blue diamond) were popular choices.
  • Mixed Cat Litter: It was seen as a promising solution aimed at balancing various demands. For example, mixing tofu with bentonite could improve clumping and odor removal while reducing dust and weight. Mixing cassava with tofu, bentonite, or apple wood attempted to combine the advantages of natural materials with high performance. Brands like Pidan, Honey Care, and Catssay all launched characteristic mixed cat litter products.

4.2. Consumers' Key Decision-Making Factors

When choosing cat litter, consumers usually weigh their needs and priorities.

  • Basic Performance: Good clumping ability and water absorption are basic requirements, directly related to the convenience of cleaning and the effective lifespan of the cat litter.
  • Odor Control: Odor removal effects are crucial factors for many families, directly affecting the comfort of the living environment.
  • Secondary but Important Factors:
    • Health and Safety: Dust levels (related to respiratory health), raw material safety (whether it can be accidentally ingested, whether it contains potential harmful substances like mold toxins or chemical additives) are core concerns.
    • Convenience: Including the ease of scooping (whether clumping is firm), whether it can be flushed down the toilet, the weight of the cat litter itself, and the severity of tracking issues.
    • Cost: Budget is an important constraint in actual purchasing decisions.
    • Environmental Impact: Whether it is biodegradable, the sustainability of the raw material source, and other eco-friendly factors are attractive to some consumers.
    • Cat-Specific Needs: The cat's age (kittens or older cats may need softer, low-dust cat litter), health conditions (such as urinary system diseases requiring highly absorbent cat litter), and individual preferences (for specific textures or odors) also need to be considered.

4.3. Practical Usage Precautions

  • Litter Box Compatibility: Different types of cat litter may require differently designed litter boxes. For example, disintegrating wood shavings usually need to be used with double-layer litter boxes. Automatic litter boxes have specific requirements for litter particle size, clumping speed, and hardness, and not all cat litters are applicable.
  • Proper Handling Method: Strictly follow the product instructions for handling. Non-flushable cat litter (such as bentonite, crystal sand, and most cassava sand) should be disposed of as regular garbage. Flushable tofu cat litter should also be thrown into the toilet in small quantities, in batches, and with sufficient water flow. Some plant-based litters can be used for composting.
  • Storage Conditions: Especially for plant-based cat litters like tofu and cassava, they should be stored in a dry, cool place, avoiding moisture, mold growth, or pest infestation.
  • Cleaning Frequency: Regardless of the type of cat litter used, it is essential to develop a habit of cleaning the litter box at least 1-2 times a day and thoroughly replacing the entire litter and washing the litter box every 2-4 weeks to maintain hygiene and optimal performance.

The effective management of cat litter is not just dependent on the choice of cat litter itself, but is a systemic project. The type of litter box (open, closed, top-entry, or automatic), whether a litter mat is used, proper storage and handling methods, and most importantly, regular cleaning and maintenance, all have a significant impact on the final user experience and the performance of the cat litter. For example, a cat litter that is prone to tracking, when paired with an efficient litter mat and a closed litter box, can effectively mitigate its drawbacks. Plant-based cat litters sensitive to humidity must be stored properly to avoid problems. The popularity of automatic litter boxes has also brought new compatibility considerations. This suggests that when recommending or choosing cat litter, it is necessary to consider the user's specific usage environment and habits. Retailers can improve user experience by bundling compatible products (such as specific cat litter with suitable litter boxes or litter mats). Manufacturers should clearly indicate the best usage methods and compatibility information in the product instructions. Ultimately, the "best" cat litter choice often varies depending on the person, cat, and environment.

5. Conclusion and Strategic Recommendations

5.1. Review of Core Findings

This report conducted an in-depth analysis of four mainstream types of cat litter, revealing their respective advantages and inherent trade-offs:

  • Tofu Cat Litter: Marketed for its eco-friendliness and flushability, but faces challenges in terms of performance stability (later-stage dust, odor control), hygiene risks (moisture, mold toxins), and cost.
  • Yam Cat Litter: Positioned as a high-end natural alternative, aiming to match or surpass mineral litter in performance (clumping, odor control, low dust), but is priced higher, has limited purchasing channels, and faces common issues with plant-based cat litter, such as tracking and storage.
  • Sodium-Based Bentonite Cat Litter: Dominates the market with its unparalleled clumping ability, widely recognized odor control, high cat acceptance, and low price; however, its severe dust issues, environmental impact, heaviness, non-flushability, and tracking problems are also widely criticized.
  • Mixed Cat Litter: Responds to the limitations of single materials by scientifically blending different materials and additives to provide more balanced and optimized performance, but its effectiveness highly depends on the specific formula, and increases the complexity of choice.

5.2. Prioritized and Customized Recommendations

Consumers' needs vary, and choosing cat litter should be decided based on the most valued factors:

  • Pursuing ultimate odor control and clumping performance: Prioritize high-quality sodium-based bentonite cat litter or performance-oriented, well-formulated mixed cat litter.
  • Highly concerned about environmental sustainability: Choose tofu cat litter, yam cat litter, or other plant-based cat litter (such as wood shavings, corn, or paper litter). Weigh whether the convenience of flushability (tofu cat litter prioritized) or overall performance (yam or high-quality mixed cat litter may be more optimal) is needed.
  • Limited budget: Sodium-based bentonite cat litter remains the most cost-effective option.
  • Pursuing maximum convenience (flushability): Tofu cat litter is the primary option (but note the usage specifications and potential risks), or choose specific mixed cat litter formulas that are clearly labeled as flushable.
  • Concerned about health risks (dust, sensitivity): Select strictly de-dusted low-dust bentonite cat litter, yam cat litter, initial-use tofu cat litter, or consider almost dust-free crystal cat litter or paper litter.
  • Ensuring cat acceptance: Sodium-based bentonite cat litter or mixed cat litter with a higher proportion of bentonite typically has the highest cat acceptance.

5.3. Market Outlook and Future Trends

  • Continuous growth: Driven by pet humanization and consumption upgrades, the global cat litter market is expected to maintain growth.
  • Hybrid innovation: Mixed cat litter will be the main direction of future innovation, with manufacturers exploring new material combinations and functional additives to meet more diversified market demands.
  • Health and environmental orientation: Concerns about sustainability, raw material safety, and low dust-related health features will continue to rise, putting pressure on traditional bentonite cat litter and creating opportunities for high-performance natural or hybrid alternatives.
  • Transparency and standardization: As the variety of mixed cat litter increases, clear product ingredient labels and reliable third-party performance tests (such as the services provided) will become increasingly important for helping consumers make informed choices.
  • Industry upgrade: Traditional production bases like Ningcheng may accelerate their transformation towards research-driven, high-value, and innovative product manufacturing to maintain global competitiveness.

In summary, given that all single-material cat litters have inherent defects that are difficult to overcome, and the market's positive feedback and growth trend for mixed cat litter are clear, the main innovation direction of the future cat litter market is likely to be intelligent "hybrid" solutions. By carefully adjusting the proportion of different raw materials and adding functional ingredients, manufacturers can more accurately balance performance, cost, convenience, and environmental friendliness, thereby more effectively meeting diversified consumer demands than attempting to perfect single materials. This means manufacturers should increase investment in the research and development of mixed cat litter, focusing on optimizing key performance indicators, controlling costs, and addressing specific pain points (such as truly efficient low-dust technology and safe, reliable flushable formulas). Retailers should provide more diversified and high-quality mixed cat litter options. For consumers, the future will bring more rich and complex cat litter options, but they will also need to rely on more reliable information sources (such as standardized tests and clear labels) to distinguish between good and bad products.

引用的著作

  1. “猫砂之乡”搭上“它经济”快车 - 新浪新闻, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://news.sina.com.cn/zx/gj/2025-04-11/doc-inesteup8891378.shtml
  2. 世界工厂进阶战：解码宁城猫砂产业突围路径-盟市新闻, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， http://m.nmgnews.com.cn/msxw/system/2025/04/03/030126746.shtml
  3. 膨润土猫砂市场规模、份额、增长|报告[2029], 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.fortunebusinessinsights.com/zh/bentonite-cat-litter-market-107148
  4. 猫砂市场规模、行业份额|预测，2032 年, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.fortunebusinessinsights.com/zh/cat-litter-market-106214
  5. “它经济”观察|世界猫咪“爱”中国猫砂 - 新华网, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， http://www.news.cn/local/20240530/01545d8cf8f144b3a8f1e1c213792a75/c.html
  6. 全球膨润土猫砂市场：产业分析、规模、占有率、成长、趋势和预测（2024-2031 年） - 日商环球讯息有限公司(GII), 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://cn.gii.tw/report/pmrs1623903-bentonite-cat-litter-market-global-industry.html
  7. 【貓砂評比】好貓砂一定要有這些特點!選礦砂還是豆腐砂?獸醫師告訴你優缺點!, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://leedecat.com/%E3%80%90%E8%B2%93%E7%A0%82%E8%A9%95%E6%AF%94%E3%80%91%E5%A5%BD%E8%B2%93%E7%A0%82%E4%B8%80%E5%AE%9A%E8%A6%81%E6%9C%89%E9%80%99%E4%BA%9B%E7%89%B9%E9%BB%9E%E9%81%B8%E7%A4%A6%E7%A0%82%E9%82%84%E6%98%AF/
  8. 6款貓砂種類大解密！教你貓砂怎麼選 - 毛好多, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://shop.iscopet.com/Article/Detail/87104
  9. 礦砂挑選指南｜礦砂有什麼優點、缺點？一張表看礦砂、豆腐砂差異 ..., 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.meow-servant.com/zh-TW/blogs/school/173881
  10. 豆腐貓砂是什麼？2024最推薦的豆腐貓砂大揭密！ - 毛孩時代, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.petstimes.com.tw/blogs/news/150236
  11. 貓砂種類比較懶人包！一篇選到適合貓砂，讓貓主子從此愛上上廁所, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.wuzzyfuzzy.co/page/Cat-catlitter-types
  12. 可沖馬桶的「豆腐砂」是什麼？所有優缺點一次看 - 毛孩市集, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://petpetgo.com/article/tofu210513?ppgclid=6k1admxlrs
  13. 3 分鐘了解貓咪豆腐砂！豆腐砂優缺點、適合貓咪完整解析 - 汪喵星球, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.dogcatstar.com/blog/blog_tofulitter/
  14. 测了20款猫砂，猫咪最爱的原来是它_上观新闻, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.jfdaily.com/sgh/detail?id=1070985
  15. 豆腐猫砂检出多项残留混合猫砂的整体性能好, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.ccn.com.cn/Content/2023/07-11/1448579641.html
  16. 6类「猫砂」全面对比，如何为你的毛宝贝选择最佳“屎”伴？ - SGS, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.sgsonline.com.cn/case/article/detail-4630.html
  17. 2024熱門貓砂是這個!獸醫師詳解豆腐砂優缺點，挑選最適合濕熱氣候的豆腐砂 - 凱舒貓砂, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.kysonpet.com/blogs/news/167910
  18. 5大貓砂種類與價格評比！哪種貓砂最適合你家貓主子？, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.pet100pa.com/about_pet/detail/%E8%B2%93%E7%A0%82%E7%A8%AE%E9%A1%9E
  19. 2024 人氣貓砂推薦！教你從不同貓砂類型和貓砂盆挑出適合 ... - 毛好多, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://shop.iscopet.com/Article/Detail/77301
  20. Best Natural Cat Litter: A Guide for Cat Owners - Litter-Robot, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.litter-robot.com/blog/best-natural-cat-litter/
  21. Non-Stick Strong Clumping Cat Litter, Unscented Dust-Free Cassava Cat Litter, Easy to Scoop, Light Color for Health Tracking, for Automatic/Stinless Steel/Plastic Cat Litter Box 3 x 5Lb - Amazon.com, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.amazon.com/Non-Stick-Clumping-Unscented-Dust-Free-Automatic/dp/B0DN5GWRDR
  22. Sustainably Yours Cat Litter: In-Depth Review (2024) - Tuft + Paw, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.tuftandpaw.com/blogs/cat-guides/sustainably-yours-cat-litter-review
  23. FUKUMARU Cassava Cat Litter, Strong Clumping Cat Litter Bulk, Plant-Based Natural Ingredients, Non-Stick Base, Low Dust, 24/7 Odor Control, Unscented, 6lb x 4bags - Amazon.com, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.amazon.com/FUKUMARU-Plant-Based-Ingredients-Non-Stick-Unscented/dp/B0DSZM4YRX
  24. Unbiased Sustainably Yours Litter Review - Cats.com, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://cats.com/sustainably-yours-litter-review
  25. Thinking about switching to Sustainably Yours Litter… Thoughts? : r/litterrobot - Reddit, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.reddit.com/r/litterrobot/comments/18ks9rs/thinking_about_switching_to_sustainably_yours/
  26. 新手貓奴看這邊！貓砂種類百百種，該怎麼選？, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.maowupet.com/blog/posts/%E6%96%B0%E6%89%8B%E8%B2%93%E5%A5%B4%E7%9C%8B%E9%80%99%E9%82%8A%EF%BC%81%E8%B2%93%E7%A0%82%E7%A8%AE%E9%A1%9E%E7%99%BE%E7%99%BE%E7%A8%AE%EF%BC%8C%E8%A9%B2%E6%80%8E%E9%BA%BC%E9%81%B8%EF%BC%9F%EF%BC%88%E8%B6%85%E8%A9%B3%E7%B4%B0%E7%AF%87%EF%BC%89
  27. CN113455409A - 混合猫砂- Google Patents, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://patents.google.com/patent/CN113455409A/zh
  28. CN110612913A - 一种具有降解功能的高吸水性易结团猫砂及其制备方法 - Google Patents, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://patents.google.com/patent/CN110612913A/zh
  29. 测了20款猫砂，猫咪最爱的原来是它| 申评测 - 中国质量新闻网, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://m.cqn.com.cn/ms/content/2023-07/10/content_8957864.htm
  30. 【CAT MAGIC魔淨貓】天然鈉基膨潤土貓砂6.35 KG/14磅X3包/箱(礦砂低粉塵用量省凝結便宜), 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.momoshop.com.tw/goods/GoodsDetail.jsp?i_code=11638172
  31. 礦砂是什麼？礦砂好用嗎？貓咪礦砂優缺點、適合族群完整指南- 汪喵 ..., 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.dogcatstar.com/blog/blog_orelitter/
  32. (12)发明专利, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/b7/21/8b/f5f5e0dfcec2a9/CN101810146B.pdf
  33. 新鮮出爐！2025年最受歡迎的10款貓砂推薦 - 寵物公園, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.wonderpet.asia/blog/14592/
  34. FUKUMARU 豆腐貓砂,15 磅(約5.4 公斤)結塊貓砂,無塵無香味可沖式豆腐貓砂,自然,輕盈低追蹤貓砂顆粒混合蘋果木,24/7 異味控制 - Amazon.com, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.amazon.com/-/zh_TW/FUKUMARU-%E8%B1%86%E8%85%90%E8%B2%93%E7%A0%82-%E7%B5%90%E5%A1%8A%E8%B2%93%E7%A0%82-%E7%84%A1%E5%A1%B5%E7%84%A1%E9%A6%99%E5%91%B3%E5%8F%AF%E6%B2%96%E5%BC%8F%E8%B1%86%E8%85%90%E8%B2%93%E7%A0%82-%E8%BC%95%E7%9B%88%E4%BD%8E%E8%BF%BD%E8%B9%A4%E8%B2%93%E7%A0%82%E9%A1%86%E7%B2%92%E6%B7%B7%E5%90%88%E8%98%8B%E6%9E%9C%E6%9C%A8/dp/B09VGMV6NV
  35. 从一袋猫砂到一个品牌，福丸FUKUMARU传达自然舒适生活方式 - 中国发展网, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， http://www.chinadevelopment.com.cn/zxsd/2023/0605/1842513.shtml
  36. 宠物猫砂检测- CTI华测检测, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.cti-cert.com/service/19639.html
  37. 每日万吨运全球内蒙古小城猫砂经济正夯 - 中国新闻网, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://backend.chinanews.com/cj/2024/05-18/10219183.shtml
  38. “世界猫砂工厂”大本营：中国乡镇企业正蓬勃生长 - 东方财富, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://wap.eastmoney.com/a/202405183080734370.html
  39. 赤峰市宁城县人民政府网_今日宁城, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， http://www.ningchengxian.gov.cn/zzllms/zzllmscfyw/index_30.html
  40. 宁城猫砂企业奋力抢占国际市场 - 内蒙古频道- 人民网, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， http://nm.people.com.cn/n2/2025/0303/c192247-41151560.html
  41. 测了20款猫砂，猫咪最爱的原来是它| 申评测 - 上观, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.jfdaily.com/sgh/detail?id=1070524
  42. Amazon.com: FEELING BEST 豆腐貓砂5 磅(約2.5 公斤)快速結塊、無塵、100% 天然原料, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.amazon.com/-/zh_TW/FEELING-BEST-%E8%B1%86%E8%85%90%E8%B2%93%E7%A0%82-%E5%BF%AB%E9%80%9F%E7%B5%90%E5%A1%8A%E3%80%81%E7%84%A1%E5%A1%B5%E3%80%81100-%E5%A4%A9%E7%84%B6%E5%8E%9F%E6%96%99%E3%80%81%E7%B5%90%E5%A1%8A%E3%80%81%E5%8F%AF%E6%B2%96%E6%B4%97%E3%80%81%E8%B6%85%E5%90%B8%E6%B0%B4%E4%B8%94%E5%BF%AB%E4%B9%BE/dp/B0CNLZSS3M
  43. 10 大貓砂推薦排行榜【2025最新】 - mybest, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://tw.my-best.com/10186
  44. 木薯貓砂：四種配比，混合更好用！ - mao & kou, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.mao-select.com.tw/mao/blog-detail/%E6%AF%9B%E5%AD%A9%E6%88%91%E8%B7%9F%E4%BD%A0%E8%AA%AA/%E6%AF%9B%E5%AD%A9%E7%9F%A5%E8%AD%98/%E6%9C%A8%E8%96%AF%E8%B2%93%E7%A0%82%E5%85%A8%E6%96%B0%E4%B8%8A%E5%B8%82/
  45. pidan 木薯貓砂原味(木薯砂) - mao & kou 美好的貓狗生活, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.mao-select.com.tw/mao/product-detail/M3PD15011213/
  46. 【 值得１柿.ᐟ 】懂柿小貓｜6 in 1 柿單寧抗臭木薯混合貓砂2.6kg［1.5mm椰殼活性碳－咖包／原味］［６入箱裝］ - Catssay貓有話說, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://www.catssay.com.tw/products/litter
  47. 猫为何主导了宠物市场的增长？ - 财联社, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， https://m.cls.cn/detail/768877
  48. 别了，一铲子真爱 - 中国青年网, 访问时间为 四月 22, 2025， http://news.youth.cn/sz/202004/t20200424_12301398.htm